Buddhist and Christian Worship Compared

The earlier forms of Buddhist ceremonials are of theYet though the scenic effect may be similar, there is
synagogue type (though in no way derived fromoften a difference in the nature of the rite. Direct
Jewish sources) for, though there is no prayer, theyinvocations are not wanting in Tibetan and Far Eastern
consist chiefly of confession, preaching and reading theBuddhism but many services consist not of prayers
scriptures. But this puritanic severity could not bebut of the recitation of scripture by which merit is
popular and the veneration of images and relics wasacquired. This merit is then formally transferred by the
soon added to the ritual. The former was adopted byofficiants to some special object, such as the peace
Buddhism earlier than by the Brahmans. The latter,of the dead or the prosperity of a living suppliant.
though a conspicuous feature of Buddhism in all lands,The later phases of both Hinduism and Buddhism are
is almost unknown to Hinduism.permeated by what is called Tantrism, that is to say
In their later developments Buddhist and Christianthe endeavour to attain spiritual ends by ritual acts
ceremonies show an extraordinary resemblance duesuch as gestures and the repetition of formulae. These
in my opinion chiefly to convergence, though I do notexpedients are dangerous and may become puerile,
entirely exclude mutual influence. Both Buddhism andbut those who ridicule them often forget that they
Roman Catholicism accepted pagan ritual with somemay be termed sacramental with as much propriety
reservations and refinements. The worship has for itsas magical and are in fact based on the same theory
object an image or a shrine containing a relic which isas the sacraments of the Catholic Church. When a
placed in a conspicuous position at the end of the hallchild is made eligible for salvation by sprinkling with
of worship. Animal sacrifices are rejected but offeringswater, by the sign of the cross and by the mantra "In
of flowers, lights and incense are permitted, as well asthe Name of the Father," etc., or when the divine spirit
the singing of hymns. It is not altogether strange ifis localized in bread and wine and worshiped, these
Buddhist and Catholic rituals starting from the samerites are closely analogous to tantric ceremonial.
elements ended by producing similar scenic effects.