Parshat Ki Tavo - What's Wrong With a Little Rebuke?

Fifty-four verses! That's how many verses in ParshatA famous Chassidic rabbi had a very learned
Ki Tavo dedicated to telling us all the awful things thatgrandson, who one night stayed up excessively late
will happen to us if we do not follow God's Torah.studying. So much so that he eventually passed out on
There is a widely accepted custom that when thishis desk and slept a solid chunk later than normal.
section is read publicly it is read in a very soft tone.His grandfather walked into the room and found him
Also, it seems it's the only time during the entire yearsleeping. His interpretation: My lazy grandson is just
where people do not want to be called up for thesleeping in and wasting away his whole morning.
public Torah readings.He woke his grandson and, thinking he was in the right,
Now, I get that people fear rebuke. And I understandtore him apart for sleeping away the precious day.
people don't want to be the focal point of the entireThe grandson simply listened and waited for his
room when this fearful rebuke is announced.grandfather to finish all he had to say. He sat silently.
But something about these customs has alwaysNo response, not during the rebuke, nor after.
bothered me, and I've dedicated this article toAn onlooker questioned the boy, inquiring why he didn't
expressing why.defend himself when it was obviously all just a big
I have always understood that the ability to calmlymisunderstanding.
accept rebuke is considered an obviously fundamental,The answer was simple, and beautiful: "Are you
quality character trait.kidding? How could I possibly miss out on an
There is one point in the Torah where Moshe (Moses)opportunity to be rebuked by a man so great as my
Rabbeinu rips into someone, misinterpreting theirgrandfather!?"
previous statements. Instead of interrupting Moshe toHow fantastic!
explain why his rebuke was unreasonable, orWe have a personal obligation to not only learn to
screaming at him for his mistreatment, he waited foraccept rebuke, but to learn how to perceive every
Moshe to finish, and then calmly explained the error.moment of the rebuke as placing a powerful, indelible
But they had full right to be upset?mark on one's soul that inherently makes you a
Why not interrupt? Why not emote? Why should yougreater person.
let someone stomp on you with their erroneousWhy then have we created a system where we
criticisms?show only fear and withdrawal in the face of rebuke
The answer to this question is very nicely illustrated byfrom the Almighty Himself?
a story I once heard: